Motivating Students to Learn
The following are the objectives of this chapter:
Possible Problems and Solutions
1. Students are sometimes overwhelmed by the apparently huge amount of information in Table 5.1 in the textbook and the accompanying discussion. This information is important, and the best way to deal with it may be to approach it in segments. Workbook Figures 5.1 through 5.6 introduce textbook Table 5.1 in small steps and in logical order.
Workbook Figures 5.1 and 5.2 show the major factors that comprise intrinsic motivation. These two diagrams go together. The only reason they have been put on two pages is that putting them on a single diagram becomes excessively cluttered.![]()
Figure 5.1 (above)
Workbook Figure 5.1 shows the individual factors that stimulate intrinsic motivation (that is, factors within the human mind or personality that stimulate learners to engage in activities for the interest and enjoyment that accompanies these activities). Figure 5.1 is expanded in Figures 5.3 through 5.6 below.
![]()
Figure 5.2 (above)
Workbook Figure 5.2 shows the interpersonal factors that stimulate intrinsic motivation (that is, factors that operate in group settings to stimulate learners to engage in activities for the interest and enjoyment that accompanies these activities).
It was impossible to describe the individual factors in detail in Figure 5.1; and so those figures are further described in Figures 5.3 through 5.6.
![]()
Figure 5.3 (above)
Workbook Figure 5.3 describes challenge. {This diagram is an expansion of Figure 5.1.} It shows that learners are likely to be motivated by tasks at a continuously optimal level of difficulty when (1) the learners set and internalize clear goals, (2) the probability of success is neither extremely easy nor extremely difficult, (3) the learners receive clear, constructive, and encouraging feedback about their status with regard to their goals, and (4) the learners derive feelings of self-worth and competence from completing the tasks.
![]()
Figure 5.4 (above)
Workbook Figure 5.4 describes curiosity. {This diagram is an expansion of Figure 5.1.} It shows that learners can be motivated by either variations in the sensory environment or intriguing cognitive aspects of information that is presented to them.
![]()
Figure 5.5 (above)
Workbook Figure 5.5 describes control. {This diagram is an expansion of Figure 5.1.} It shows that learners can attain a feeling of self-determination and control by (1) seeing obvious connections between what they do and important outcomes they can accomplish, (2) perceiving themselves as making free choices to engage in activities rather than being coerced by someone else, and (3) feeling that the outcomes they accomplish are really important.
![]()
Figure 5.6 (above)
Workbook Figure 5.6 describes fantasy. {This diagram is an expansion of Figure 5.1.} It shows that learners can participate in interesting activities in their imagination by (1) imagining events that appeal to their emotional needs and by (2) imagining events that demonstrate an understanding or ability to apply information being learned. It also shows that (3) the imagined events can be more motivating to the extent that they are naturally related to the information being learned.
2. Students are sometimes confused by important aspects of attribution theory. This information is important. The best way to approach it may be to look specifically at the definition of key attributions in terms of whether each is internal or external, stable or unstable, and controllable or uncontrollable.
Effort is internal, unstable, and controllable. This means that effort comes from inside a person, that it can easily be different on one occasion than on another, and that the person performing the activity has control over how much effort will be expended.If a test is hard but the student thinks it will probably be easier next time if she approaches it differently, this is an effort attribution.
- The reason for success is internal (There's something inside her - the way she approached the task - that caused her performance to be less than satisfactory.)
- The likelihood of success is unstable. (The outcome will not necessarily be the same in the future. It will perhaps be different if she approaches the test differently.)
- She does have control over the outcome. (She can change the way she approaches her preparation for the test.)
Ability is internal, stable, and uncontrollable. This means that ability exists inside a person, that it is not likely to be different on one occasion than on another, and that the person performing the activity has little control over how much ability he or she will possess.
If a test is hard and the student thinks it will probably still be hard the next time, even if he approaches it differently, because he simply cannot master something that difficult, this is an ability attribution.
- The reason for success is internal (The inability to master the material arises inside him. Note that if the focus were on task difficulty, other people would experience difficulty too. It must be something inside himself that is making his performance unsatisfactory.)
- The likelihood of success is stable. (He expects a similar outcome, because he lacks the capability to do better.
- He has no control over the outcome. (He cannot increase his capability by wishing or working harder. He lacks the ability to do better without unreasonable effort.)
Note that if this person changed the last two explanations and said, "Maybe I could do better if I worked harder," this attribution would become internal, unstable, and controllable, which would make it an effort attribution.
Task Difficulty is external, stable, and uncontrollable. This means that the reason a task is difficult (or easy) lies in the task itself, not in the person approaching the task, that the probability of success is not likely to be different on one occasion than on another, and that the person performing the activity has little control over whether he or she will succeed at the task.
If a test is hard and the student thinks it will probably be equally hard the next time, even if she studies harder, this is a task difficulty attribution.
- The reason for success is external (There's nothing inside her that caused her to do badly. It must be something in the task itself.)
- The likelihood of success is stable. (She expects the same outcome, even if she herself would work harder.)
- She has no control over the outcome. (She can identify nothing she can do to change the outcome. It's just a difficult task.)
Luck is external, unstable, and uncontrollable. This means that the reason a task is difficult (or easy) lies outside the person, but not necessarily in the task itself, that the probability of success is likely to be different on one occasion than on another, and that the person performing the activity has little control over whether he or she will succeed at the task.
If a test is hard but the student thinks it will probably be easier next time, even though he has no plans to approach it differently, this is a luck attribution.
- The reason for success is external (There's nothing inside him that caused him to do badly. It must be some unspecified thing outside himself.)
- The likelihood of success is unstable. (He expects a different outcome, even though he is acting the same.)
- He has no control over the outcome. (He can identify nothing he can do to change the outcome.)
3. Students sometimes think that attributing failure to effort is the same thing as saying that the person who failed did not work hard. In other words, we are accusing the person who failed of being lazy.
Basis for the confusion: If a person failed because he did not put forth the effort, it seems obvious that he should have put forth more effort. Since he could have put forth more effort and did not do so, it sounds like he was lazy.Clarification: Sometimes (perhaps often), all a person has to do to succeed after an effort attribution for failure is work harder - that is, spend more time on the task or stop being lazy. In many other cases, however, the person must work differently, not necessarily harder. It is reasonable for a person to feel that he has failed because he has not yet figured out the right way to approach the task. If a person does so, this is an effort attribution.
- If he feels he will never figure out the right way, this is an ability attribution.
- If he feels that there is no better way to approach the task, this is a task difficulty attribution.
Insinuating that a person is lazy may actually lead to an ability attribution, if the person is led to believe that he possesses a trait called laziness. The most supportive strategy when a person fails at a task is often to convince the person that he can succeed if he approaches the task differently. It is possible that this different approach will consist of spending more time on the task; but it is also possible that the different approach will consist of using a new strategy that the teacher helps him develop.
1. Carla's class is part of the Galaxy Program. As part of one of the Galaxy activities, she has entered information about herself into a computerized database and has searched the database to find the other person who is most similar to her and has become an electronic pen pal with that person. She finds it to be very interesting to learn about this other person, and so she is motivated to continue participating in the program. Which motivational factor seems to be most responsible for maintaining Carla's active participation in the program?
a. Challenge - uncertain outcomes
b. Challenge - self esteem
c. Curiosity - cognitive curiosity
d. Control - choice
e. Interpersonal motivations - recognition
2. Bill feels that he already knows how to spell. He thinks he is the best speller in the class and that he doesn't have to study. He gets 80's and 90's on all his tests, but his teacher would like him to do better. She arranges a spelling competition between her class and the other two fifth grades in the school. Bill realizes that there may be some better spellers in these other classes, and so he studies harder. Pretty soon he is getting almost all 100's on his tests. Which motivational factor seems to be most responsible for increasing Bill's effort to study spelling?
a. Challenge - uncertain outcomes
b. Challenge - self esteem
c. Curiosity - cognitive curiosity
d. Control - choice
e. Interpersonal motivations - recognition
3. Mary feels that she is a terrible speller. She gets 30's and 40's on all her tests, but her teacher would like her to do better. She is certain she will get an F in language arts; and so she sees no point in studying very hard. Mary's teacher shows her some good ways to sound out words and to follow some simple rules in order to spell the words correctly. Mary realizes that if she follows these guidelines she may get a much higher grade than she had expected. She begins to work harder and does much better on her spelling tests. Which motivational factor seems to be most responsible for increasing Mary's effort to study spelling?
a. Challenge - uncertain outcomes
b. Challenge - self esteem
c. Curiosity - cognitive curiosity
d. Control - choice
e. Interpersonal motivations - recognition
4. As Mary (Question 3) begins using her new strategy, she wants to motivate herself to stick to her use of the guidelines. She keeps a graph of her performance, and she notices that her scores go from 30's and 40's upward to 70's and 80's and eventually into the 90's. Which motivational factor is Mary using to maintain her effort to study spelling?
a. Challenge - level of certainty
b. Challenge - performance feedback
c. Curiosity - cognitive curiosity
d. Fantasy - emotional aspects
e. Interpersonal motivations - recognition
5. Mary's teacher (Questions 3 and 4) divides the class into four spelling teams. An award will be given to the team that spells the most words correctly on the final test. The teams are reasonably equal at the beginning of the contest. The students are allowed to help one another study. Since Mary wants her team to win, she studies hard. Which motivational factor is Mary using to maintain her effort to study spelling?
a. Challenge - setting goals
b. Challenge - performance feedback
c. Curiosity - cognitive curiosity
d. Interpersonal motivations - competition
e. Interpersonal motivations - recognition
1. To which of the following factors did Bill (Intrinsic Motivation Exercise, Question 2) originally attribute his success in spelling?
a. Luck
b. Effort
c. Ability
d. Task difficulty
2. To which of the following factors did Mary (Intrinsic Motivation Exercise, Question 3 through 5) originally attribute her failure in spelling?
a. Luck
b. Effort
c. Ability
d. Task difficulty
3. This attribution (Question 2) was
a. internal, unstable, and controllable
b. internal, unstable, and uncontrollable
c. external, unstable, and uncontrollable
d. external, unstable, and controllable
e. external, stable, and uncontrollable
4. As her scores improved, Mary (Questions 2 and 3) said to herself, "These new methods really pay off. I think I'll keep using them." To which of the following factors did Mary attribute her success in spelling?
a. Luck
b. Effort
c. Ability
d. Task difficulty
5. This attribution (Questions 4) was
a. internal, unstable, and controllable
b. internal, unstable, and uncontrollable
c. external, unstable, and uncontrollable
d. external, unstable, and controllable
e. external, stable, and uncontrollable
Questions 1 through 7 go together:
1. Miss Ramirez tells Juan that if he does well during the tryouts, he will be captain of the team for the Science Bowl. Juan likes this idea and studies hard for the tryouts. On which motivational factor has Miss Ramirez most directly focused Juan's attention?
a. Challenge - uncertain outcomes
b. Challenge - self esteem
c. Curiosity - cognitive curiosity
d. Control - choice
e. Fantasy - cognitive aspects{Check your answer.}
2. Juan is confident that he can do well on the science tryouts, but he knows that Margarita has always surpassed him. Miss Ramirez points out that Margarita will be out of town for a chess tournament that weekend, and so she will not be competing with Juan for the captain's role. On which motivational factor has Miss Ramirez now most directly focused Juan's attention?
a. Challenge - uncertain outcomes
b. Challenge - self esteem
c. Curiosity - cognitive curiosity
d. Control - choice
e. Fantasy - cognitive aspects{Check your answer.}
3. Juan studies hard for the tryouts, because he pictures himself as captain of a winning Science Bowl team. He studies a certain number of key concepts every night for a week. His mother asks him questions and keeps a record of his progress, which she posts on the refrigerator door. Juan knows that two of his friends also want to be captain, but he thinks he has a reasonable chance to beat them. Juan feels no animosity toward these friends, because he knows that even if he loses the role of captain, the extra studying will dramatically improve the chances that the team will win. Juan is being specifically motivated by all but one of the following factors. Choose the EXCEPTION.
a. Challenge - uncertain outcomes
b. Challenge - performance feedback
c. Curiosity - cognitive curiosity
d. Interpersonal motivations - competition
e. Interpersonal motivations - recognition{Check your answer.}
4. On the day before the tryouts, Juan is becoming anxious; and the anxiety is making it hard to concentrate on his studies. His mother wants to help him. Which of the following would be his mother's best strategy?
a. Promise him a Type I reinforcer if he manages to study effectively.
b. Promise him a Type II or III reinforcer if he manages to study effectively.
c. Encourage him to focus on self-actualization
d. Do something to reduce his level of arousal.
e. Do something to increase his level of arousal.{Check your answer.}
Use this information for questions 5 through 7:
Juan eventually comes in second in the race for captain, and his friend Julio becomes captain. Juan's mother is happy that Juan worked so hard, and she would like to see him continue to work hard at other academic activities. She assures Juan that he learned a great deal of interesting information while studying for the Science Bowl. Juan thinks it over, and realizes that his mother is right. She also assures him that by giving Julio a run for his money, he helped the team do better in the Science Bowl. Since the team won a silver medal, Juan accepts this statement as true and is happy about his contribution. Finally, his mother helps him analyze his study habits, and Juan realizes that there are certain things that he could do better next time in order to be even more successful.
5. When she assured Juan that he learned a great deal of interesting information while studying for the Science Bowl, on what factor of motivational theory was Juan's mother focusing?
a. curiosity - cognitive curiosity
b. attribution theory - effort
c. attribution theory - ability
d. Maslow's needs theory - belonging and love needs
e. Interpersonal motivation - competition{Check your answer.}
6. When she assured Juan that by giving Julio a run for his money, he helped the team do better in the Science Bowl, on what factor of motivational theory was Juan's mother focusing?
a. curiosity - cognitive curiosity
b. attribution theory - effort
c. attribution theory - ability
d. Maslow's needs theory - belonging and love needs
e. Interpersonal motivation - competition{Check your answer.}
7. When she helped Juan analyze his study habits and helped him realize that there are certain things that he could do better next time in order to be more successful, on what factor of motivational theory was Juan's mother focusing?
a. curiosity - cognitive curiosity
b. attribution theory - effort
c. attribution theory - ability
d. Maslow's needs theory - belonging and love needs
e. Interpersonal motivation - competition{Check your answer.}
8. Matthew received a D in mathematics. He thinks this is because the teacher asked a lot of questions that he happened to find difficult. He thinks that he'll do better next time, because the questions probably won't be so hard. Matthew's attribution for his failure is
a. internal, unstable, and controllable
b. internal, unstable, and uncontrollable
c. external, unstable, and uncontrollable
d. external, unstable, and controllable
e. external, stable, and uncontrollable{Check your answer.}
9. Rosalie received a D in mathematics. She thinks this is because mathematics is too hard for girls. She feels that she'll probably always have trouble with mathematics. Rosalie's attribution for failure is
a. internal, unstable, and controllable
b. internal, unstable, and uncontrollable
c. external, unstable, and uncontrollable
d. external, unstable, and controllable
e. external, stable, and uncontrollable{Check your answer.}
10. Anferny received a D in mathematics. He feels he has studied hard, but he knows that there must be a better way to approach the subject, so that he can do better. Anferny's attribution for failure is
a. internal, unstable, and controllable
b. internal, unstable, and uncontrollable
c. external, unstable, and uncontrollable
d. external, unstable, and controllable
e. external, stable, and uncontrollable{Check your answer.}
Motivation - Set 1
Match each term with the appropriate definition.
a. Challenge.
b. Cognitive curiosity.
c. Competition.
d. Control.
e. Cooperation.
f. Curiosity.
g. Fantasy.
h. Interpersonal motivation.
i. Performance feedback.
j. Recognition.
k. Sensory curiosity.
Match each term with the appropriate definition.
a. Attribution theory.
b. Ability.
c. Effort.
d. External locus of control.
e. Extrinsic Motivation.
f. Internal locus of control.
g. Intrinsic Motivation.
h. Level of arousal.
i. Luck.
j. Motivation.
k. Seductive detail.
l. Self-efficacy.
m. Task difficulty.
{Click here to see answers to matching exercises.}
Motivation - Set 3
Match each term with the appropriate definition.
a. Competitive goal structure.
b. Cooperative goal structure.
c. Expectancy-valence model.
d. Individualistic goal structure.
e. Learned helplessness.
f. Learning goal.
g. Locus of control.
h. Performance goal.
i. Positive interdependence.
j. Self-fulfilling prophecy.
k. Self-Handicapping.
l. Teacher Expectancy.
(This fill-in-the-blanks exercise can be a useful way to verify that you can recall and understand the main concepts covered in this chapter. When the answers you give differ from those in the answer key, think about it. If your answer is as good as mine, that's great! However, there's a good chance that in many cases my answer may be better than yours. Try to find the logic behind my answer. The more actively you think - by looking for reasons and explanations - the more valuable this exercise will be for you.)
(Also note that after you have filled in the blanks, this set of Key Ideas provides a good summary of the chapter.)
{Click here to see answers to Key Ideas exercise.}
Answers to Quiz and Exercises:
Intrinsic Motivation Exercise
1. c2. e
3. a
4. b
5. d
Attribution Theory Exercise
1. c2. c
3. b
4. b
5. a
Motivation Unit Quiz
1. Answer to Question 1: (b) Of all the possibilities given here, challenge with a focus on self esteem seems to be the best answer. It sounds like being captain of the team is something that would make Juan feel good about himself, and she is helping him set that as a goal, which will constitute a challenge for Juan.
The answer is not (a) because Miss Ramirez is doing nothing to manipulate or modify his level of certainty. If Juan wanted to be captain but thought he couldn't and Miss Ramirez did something to increase his confidence, or if he were overconfident and she convinced him that he wouldn't be captain unless he worked harder, then the answer would be (a).Return to Question 1.
Go to Question 2.
2. Answer to Question 2: (a) Miss Ramirez is doing something to modify Juan's level of certainty. Juan wants to be captain but he thinks he has little chance, because he knows that Margarita has always surpassed him. Miss Ramirez is increasing his confidence that he can attain the outcome by telling him that he does not have to compete with Margarita this time.
The answer is not (b). Although being captain will probably be good for his self concept, this is not at all a factor in what Miss Ramirez is doing in this question. All she is doing here is maximizing the challenge by moving him to a medium level of certainty &endash; if he works, he has a chance to meet his goal.Return to Question 2.
Go to Question 3.
3. Answer to Question 3: (c) Cognitive curiosity refers to the notion that Juan would study because the information is interesting &endash; because he is simply curious to learn more about it. This may be the case, but that concept is not mentioned at all in the anecdote.
(a) is a motivating factor, because he has to work hard to beat out the other students for team captain. If he works hard he has a chance, but if he doesn't work hard he won't be captain. That's a medium level of certainty, and the anecdote says that is a factor in his motivation.(b) is a motivating factor, because Juan's mother keeps a record of his progress, which she posts on the refrigerator door.
(d) is a motivating factor, because Juan hopes to derive satisfaction from seeing his team perform better than the other teams.
(e) is a motivating factor, because Juan takes obvious pride in the idea of being recognized as captain of a successful team. Recognition refers to the notion that learners may enjoy having their efforts and accomplishments recognized and appreciated by others.
Return to Question 3.
Go to Question 4.
4. Answer to Question 4: (d) People learn best at a medium level of arousal. Since Juan is extremely anxious, it would be a good idea to do something to lower his level of arousal.
Return to Question 4.Go to Question 5.
5. Answer to Question 5: (a) Juan is also motivated by other factors, but when his mother assured Juan that he learned a great deal of interesting information while studying for the Science Bowl, she was focusing on his cognitive curiosity.
The answer is not (b). Although Juan did make serious effort that contributed to what he learned, his mother is focusing on the fact that the information was interesting.Return to Question 5.
Go to Question 6.
6. Answer to Question 6: (e) She is comparing the performance of the team (of which Juan was a part) to the performance of other teams.
The answer is not (b). Although Juan did make serious effort that contributed to the team's success, his mother is focusing on the fact that the team did well compared to the other teams.Return to Question 6.
Go to Question 7.
7. Answer to Question 7: (b) Here she is focusing on the reasons why he was successful and how he could be more successful. She is promoting the notion that he largely succeeded (and partially failed) because of factors that were inside him, that he could control, and which he could manipulate in order to change the outcome next time. That is, his attribution was internal, unstable, and controllable. That's a description of an effort attribution.
Return to Question 7.Go to Question 8.
8. Answer to Question 8: (c) This is a luck attribution. His failure occurred because of something external (outside him) - that is, the teacher is the one who wrote the hard questions. The attribution is unstable (the outcome is likely to be different next time) &endash; that is, he thinks the questions probably won't be so hard the next time. And he feels his success or failure is beyond his control. According to attribution theory, that's a definition of (c) luck. This attribution is not likely to stimulate him to study harder for the next test.
Return to Question 8.Go to Question 9.
9. Answer to Question 9: (e) This could also be an ability attribution, but internal, stable, and uncontrollable is not an option. Of the remaining choices, only (e) makes sense. The structure of mathematics is outside her, and it's complex. That structure is not going to change, and so math will always be difficult; and so it's stable. She has no control over whether she will succeed or fail, and so it's uncontrollable. That makes it an (e) task difficulty attribution. This attribution is not likely to stimulate her to study harder for the next test.
Return to Question 9.Go to Question 10.
10. Answer to Question 10: (a) This is an effort attribution. The way he studied arose from an internal decision. If he studies differently, he thinks he'll get a different result; and so the attribution is unstable. He can control how he studies, and so he believes the outcome is controllable. That makes it an (a) effort attribution. This attribution is likely to stimulate him to study harder for the next test.
Return to Question 10.
Set 1
1. a2. i
3. d
4. f
5. b
6. k
7. g
8. h
9. c
10. e
11. j
Set 2
1. j2. g
3. e
4. h
5. k
6. l
7. a
8. b
9. c
10. m
11. i
12. f
13. d
Set 3
1. f2. h
3. g
4. e
5. k
6. c
7. l
8. j
9. a
10. b
11. d
12. i
1. internal; external2. intrinsic
3. Intrinsically
4. extrinsic
5. reducing
6. intrinsic; internalized
7. optimal
8. meaningful; uncertain
9. short-term; long-term
10. short-term; long-term
11. clarifying; gamelike
12. Performance
13. challenges
14. Personally
15. links; fantasy; interpersonal
16. environment; discrepancy
17. physical
18. sensory
19. modify
20. strongest; different
21. discrepancy
22. environment
23. cause-and-effect; choose; powerful
24. loss
25. mental
26. connection
27. endogenous
28. interactions
29. self-esteem
30. satisfaction
31. accomplishments
32. bribes
33. intrinsic; artificial
34. reinforcing
35. competing; strongest
36. approach
37. positive
38. positive
39. arousal
40. low; high
41. easily: within
42. important
43. surprising
44. central
45. seductive
46. four; three
47. hierarchical
48. competent
49. self-regulatory
50. future
51. cognitive; interpret
52. maintain
53. good
54. stable
55. external
56. unstable
57. external
58. perceptions
59. persistent; effort
60. not beneficial
61. effort
62. fail; effort
63. academic learning time
64. useful
65. external
66. overestimate
67. competence
68. challenges
69. learning; performance
70. judgments
71. performance
72. undesirable
73. learned helplessness
74. more
75. impediments
76. combination
77. decline
78. expect
79. self-fulfilling
80. stereotyping
81. competitive
82. individualistic; standards
83. cooperative; succeed
84. natural; self-esteem
85. comparing; depending
86. interdependence; responsibility