Teaching Thinking Skills
The following are the objectives of this chapter:
Possible Problems and Solutions:
Students find several terms to be confusing in this chapter. A major part of the problem is that the theorists themselves are confused. It's almost impossible to look in two good books on the topic of thinking skills and find the same terms used to describe higher order thinking processes.
This section will try to help eliminate confusion about terms that are often confused. In some cases distinctions are not worth making. I'll try to point out when this is the case; and I would encourage instructors not to design test items that require students to make distinctions among such terms.
In other cases, however, the distinctions are important. Using the terms correctly can lead to more productive thought. For example, many people seem to use the term critical thinking to refer to any kind of careful thinking or problem solving. It is more productive to use this term in the way cognitive psychologists seem to have agreed to use it, and to use other terms to refer to other types of thinking or problem solving.
1. Students often think that cognitive restructuring refers to the reorganization of information in the brain. This would make sense, but this is not the way learning theorists use the term. The constant reorganization of knowledge in the brain is referred to by such terms as assimilation, accommodation, and construction of knowledge, but not cognitive restructuring These terms are discussed in Chapter 4. The term cognitive restructuring simply means that the learner uses cognitive (intellectual) processes to restructure (state in a different manner) the information that he or she is trying to process. The theorists could have used a term like self-talk to describe this process (and some do use this term), but cognitive restructuring seems to be gaining prominence as the best term. This is a learning-to-learn skill because learners who do this kind of active self-talk make it more likely that the information will be transferred from working memory to long-term memory and that it will be retrieved when it is needed for subsequent use.
2. Students often confuse the learning-to-learn skills presented at the beginning of the chapter with the metacognitive skills presented later. There is good reason for this confusion: the skills overlap considerably. It is not useful to make a distinction, for example, between self-evaluation and self-regulation. The presentation of thinking skills at the beginning of the chapter is supposed to cover all possible human thinking skills. It is not surprising, therefore, that these overlap with metacognitive skills, which are a subset of this broader category. The reason for the confusion is that the two sets of terms were developed by different people. Both sets are useful. Try to understand both and to profit from the insights, but don't worry about making distinctions among terms from the different sets.
3. Students often confuse analogical reasoning with extrapolation. The two types of basic reasoning skills are, in fact, similar. The main difference is that analogical reasoning is more refined. When people are faced with a new problem or situation, they have to use their existing knowledge to deal with it. They extrapolate by trying what they already know in the new situation.
For example, when I am using my word processor to type the draft of this, I might decide that I would this present paragraph to be indented between the preceding and subsequent paragraphs. If I am using a new word processor, I might not know how to do this. Using extrapolation, I would first try what used to work on my old word processor. When that doesn't work, I might say to myself, "What things that have worked in the past might work here?" Some of my efforts might look for fairly remote ideas (that is, I might have to extrapolate further). Using analogical reasoning, I would make a more specific comparison. I would say, "Using this set of commands is in the logic system of my MS-DOS computer comparable to what set of commands in the logic of the Macintosh computer?"It seems to me that analogical reasoning combines categorization and extrapolation: the learner first categorizes the new and old piece of information, and then makes a thoughtful comparison of important features of the two. (I need to go back to the original sources on this to get a better clarification.)
4. Some students use the term critical thinking to refer to creative thinking, to problem solving, or to any other sort of careful thinking. {This section is currently not complete in the textbook.}
5. Some students are confused by the appearance of goal setting as a thinking skill in this chapter, whereas in chapter 5 it was discussed as an aspect of intrinsic motivation. This is not a contradiction. All it means is that being able to motivate oneself is an important learning-to-learn skill.
Teaching Students to Use Analogies
Miss Hughes and a few students are discussing a story about a football player.
Miss Hughes: It says here, "The quarterback barked his signals." What analogy is the writer using?Ralph: He's saying that the quarterback was telling them when to hike the ball.
Miss Hughes: That's what he's doing, but an analogy is a comparison. What comparison is the writer making?
Bonnie: He's suggesting that the quarterback sounded like a dog.
Miss Hughes writes on the board:
Quarterback
calls signals
Miss Hughes: Ralph, finish the analogy.
As Ralph gives the answer, Miss Hughes finishes the analogy on the board:
Quarterback
Dog
calls signals
barks
Miss Hughes: John, how do you think the quarterback sounded?
John barks the signals appropriately.
Miss Hughes: Let's change the analogy.
Miss Hughes crosses out the dog information in the right column and replaces it with the following:
Quarterback
Snake
calls signals
hisses
Miss Hughes: Roberta, call the signals.
Roberta hisses the signals.
Miss Hughes: Snakes sound dangerous or hostile. What if the author wanted to say that the quarterback sounded timid and harmless? What animal could be used for the analogy?
Bonnie: A mouse.
Ralph: A small songbird.
Miss Hughes: Good ideas. So what would your sentence be, Ralph?
Miss Hughes erases the snake information and writes the following on the board, while Ralph thinks:
Quarterback
Songbird
calls signals
Miss Hughes: What do songbirds do?
John: They sing.
Miss Hughes: Let's think of a more descriptive or vivid word.
Ralph: Hey, that's great! They chirp. The quarterback chirped the signals!
Miss Hughes: I like that sentence. The quarterback doesn't scare me at all. Bonnie, what would your sentence be?
Bonnie: The quarterback squeaked his signals.
Roberta: Let's make him fierce, like a lion. The quarterback roared his signals!
(Miss Hughes is using a language arts unit on metaphorical language to demonstrate and teach analogical reasoning to her students. Similar lessons could be employed in social studies, in science, and in other curriculum areas.)
Use this information for questions 1-9
Maribeth has been learning to use a word processor to type her written assignments in college. She has discovered that if she reads a chapter of the manual and then runs the tutorial, she learns more effectively than if she runs the tutorial first and then reads the manual. At first she has trouble remembering what keys to press for certain functions (such as to delete text or to find or replace a word), but she soon discovers that the keys are usually related to the first letter of the function (such as d for delete and f for find), and so she learns to use the key commands effectively.
1. When Maribeth focuses on her realization that she learns better through one method than another and makes a decision to employ that method, she is employing
a. content thinking skills
b. metacognitive skills
c. basic reasoning skills
d. matching skills
e. storage and retrieval skills{Check your answer.}
2. When Maribeth learned that the d key enabled her to delete text, she was developing
a. a content thinking skill
b. a metacognitive skill
c. a basic reasoning skill
d. scaffolding{Check your answer.}
3. The first few times she wanted to delete text, Maribeth said to herself, "D is for delete. I'll press d to delete this text." This enabled her to remember the association between the d key and the command to delete. By saying these words to herself, Maribeth was employing a(n) _________________ to help her remember this association.
a. content thinking skill
b. goal setting skill
c. basic reasoning skill
d. scaffold
e. attention control strategy{Check your answer.}
4. Another benefit of the strategy Maribeth employed in question 3 is that she became acutely aware of what she was doing. By being aware of what she was doing, she was able to notice when she was off task and make appropriate adjustments. Which of the following terms applies to this aspect of the process of talking to herself?
a. matching skill
b. cognitive restructuring
c. basic reasoning skill
d. metacognitive skill
e. storage and retrieval skill{Check your answer.}
5. When is Maribeth demonstrating a specific example of a learning-to-learn skill?
a. When she set the goal of learning to use the word processor in order to be able to type her college assignments.
b. When she eventually learned that d meant delete.
c. When she read the manual before running the tutorial.
d. When she ran the tutorial before reading the manual.{Check your answer.}
6. Which of the following is an example of declarative knowledge?
a. Maribeth knows how to use the word processor to enter, edit, and print data.
b. Maribeth is able to delete text when she needs to do so.
c. Maribeth knows how to move text from one location to another in a manuscript on her word processor.
d. All of the above
e. None of the above.{Check your answer.}
7. Which of the following is an example of procedural knowledge?
a. Maribeth knows how to use the word processor to enter, edit, and print data.
b. Maribeth is able to delete text when she needs to do so.
c. Maribeth knows how to move text from one location to another in a manuscript on her word processor.
d. All of the above
e. None of the above.{Check your answer.}
8. Which of the following is an example of a metacognitive skill?
a. Maribeth knows how to use the word processor to enter, edit, and print data.
b. Maribeth is able to delete text when she needs to do so.
c. Maribeth knows how to move text from one location to another in a manuscript on her word processor.
d. All of the above
e. None of the above.{Check your answer.}
9. Which of the following is an example of a basic reasoning skill?
a. Maribeth knows how to use the word processor to enter, edit, and print data.
b. Maribeth is able to delete text when she needs to do so.
c. Maribeth knows how to move text from one location to another in a manuscript on her word processor.
d. All of the above
e. None of the above.{Check your answer.}
10. Jake does badly in any subject involving reading, because he reads entire passages without even realizing that he understands little of what he is reading. What skill should Jake develop, in order to become a better reader?
a. cognitive restructuring
b. metacomprehension
c. metamemory
d. matching skills
e. storage and retrieval skills{Check your answer.}
Set 1
Match each term with the appropriate definition.
a. Analogical reasoning
b. Attention control
c. Categorization
d. Cognitive restructuring
e. Composing
f. Declarative knowledge
g. Elaboration
h. Evaluation of logic
i. Evaluation of value
j. Executive procedures
k. Extrapolation
l. Goal setting
m. Matching skills
n Problem solving
o. Procedural knowledge
p. Self-evaluation.
q. Storage and retrieval skills
Set 2
Match each term with the appropriate definition.
a. Basic reasoning skills
b. Cognitive strategy instruction
c. Content thinking skills
d. Learning-to-learn skills
e. Metacognitive skills
f. Metamemory
g. Metacomprehension
h. Prior knowledge
i. Scaffolding
j. Self-Regulation
(These fill-in-the-blanks exercises can be a useful way to verify that you can recall and understand the main concepts covered in this chapter. When the answers you give differ from those in the answer key, think about it. If your answer is as good as mine, that's great! However, there's a good chance that in many cases my answer may be better than yours. Try to find the logic behind my answer. The more actively you think - by looking for reasons and explanations - the more valuable this exercise will be for you.)
(Also note that after you have filled in the blanks, this set of Key Ideas provides a good summary of the chapter.)
Answers to Quiz and Exercises:
Unit Quiz
1. Answer to Question 1: (b) Metacognitive skill are those that enable us to monitor and coordinate our other cognitive skills. In this case, Maribeth is monitoring her ability to learn from texts and is making adjustments based on what she learns about her thinking processes.
Return to Question 1.Go to Question 2.
2. Answer to Question 2: (a) This is a content thinking skill. Specifically, it is an example of declarative knowledge. If she learned how to actually apply the process and delete text it would be a procedural skill. It's a close call here, because the only reason for having the declarative knowledge is in order to perform the procedure. Nevertheless, it is definitely a content skill, which is the focus of this question. {The content is "knowledge of word processing.} Although Maribeth would use basic reasoning skills {e.g., storage and retrieval and categorization} to remember this information, the information itself is not a basic reasoning skill.
Return to Question 2.Go to Question 3.
3. Answer to Question 3: (c) She is employing a retrieval skill, which is a specific type of basic reasoning skill. The information itself is a content thinking skill {See question 2}, but what she is doing here is a basic reasoning skill.
Return to Question 3.Go to Question 4.
4. Answer to Question 4: (d) This is an example of a metacognitive skill, because Maribeth is monitoring her cognitive strategies. Self-regulation of this type is an important metacognitive skill. {Note that if attention control, which is a learning-to-learn skill, were listed, that could also be a correct answer. Some students select cognitive restructuring as the correct answer, because Maribeth is talking to herself. However, self-talk is an example of cognitive restructuring only when it occurs for the purpose of becoming actively involved with the information &endash; that is, when it produces generative learning. That is, if Maribeth were saying something to herself something like, "Now I push d for delete to get rid of this stuff," then that would be cognitive restructuring. Actually, this is a close question, and somebody will probably leave out cognitive restructuring as an alternative the next time this set of questions is revised.
Return to Question 4.Go to Question 5.
5. Answer to Question 5: (a) Goal setting is an important learning-to-learn skill. Statement (a) would be a better example of a learning-to-learn skill if it specified that Maribeth was setting the goal in such a way as to actively integrate her learning.
Return to Question 5.Go to Question 6.
6. Answer to Question 6: (e) The above are all examples of content knowledge, but they are all examples of procedural &endash; not declarative &endash; knowledge.
Return to Question 6.Go to Question 7.
7. Answer to Question 7: (d) All three of these state that Maribeth knows how to follow sets of procedures that she has learned.
Return to Question 7.Go to Question 8.
8. Answer to Question 8: (e) None of these is an example of a metacognitive skill. They are all procedural skills.
Return to Question 8.Go to Question 9.
9. Answer to Question 9: (e) None of these is an example of a metacognitive skill. They are all procedural skills.
Return to Question 9.Go to Question 10.
10. Answer to Question 10: (b). Metacomprehension is a term that applies to the ability to monitor and coordinate one's skills of comprehension. That's exactly what Jake is doing.
Return to Question 10.
Set 1
1. l2. p
3. d
4. b
5. f
6. o
7. q
8. m
9. c
10. k
11. a
12. h
13. i
14. j
15. g
16. n
17. e
Set 2
1. c2. d
3. e
4. h
5. a
6. g
7. f
8. j
9. b
10. i
Key Ideas
1. instruction2. attention; conscious
3. goals
4. Short-term
5. difference
6. purpose
7. restructuring
8. mediation; manageable
9. self-belief; clearly
10. monitoring; achieved
11 declarative; procedural
12. patterns
13. when
14. verbalize
15. errors
16. automaticity
17. prerequisites
18. cognition
19. long-term
20. Matching
21 group; generalize
22. information; unnecessary
23. similarities
24. relationships
25. logic
26. value
27. restructure
28. inferring
29. finding
30. linguistic; communicate
31. specific
32. awareness
33. knowledge
34. how
35. monitor; repair
36. understood; confusion
37. adjustments
38. consciously; automatic
39. direct
40. constructivism
41. formal; metacognitive
42. primitive; efforts; transfer
43. thinking
44. meaningful
45. framework
46. explicit; connection
47. thinking
48. aloud
49. responsibility
50. easier; responsibility
51. imitating
52. independent
53. actively